A Thorium Dream: India’s Investments in New Nuclear

July 15, 2012

Safe Nuclear Power: can it be done?

With a population of 1.2 billion 

that is expected to multiply over the next couple of decades, India has taken a keen interest in new nuclear technologies and is fast becoming a key player in the energy arena.  The International Energy Agency, an energy research organization, expects that India’s energy demand will “more than double by 2030."  It is furthermore clear that India will need to expand its power grid in order to reach the significant portion of the country that currently does not have electricity.

With pressure coming from the international community to reduce its carbon emissions, India is looking for energy investments that will pay-off in the long-term. As Rajendra K. Pachauri, chairman of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, astutely stated, “India cannot emulate developed countries. We have to find a path that is distinctly different." Part of the answer lies in India’s exploitation of new nuclear technologies.

Currently, uranium can be purchased on the market at a competitive price, which seems to preclude the much needed investment in research and development of new nuclear technologies. However, it is imperative that these newer technologies receive adequate attention because nuclear energy seems to be a likely interim fuel source for the transition from carbon-based fuels to fully-renewable energy sources. In its current state, nuclear energy does not seem to be safe or efficient enough to win wide-spread trust from citizens and policy-makers. Therefore, the need for new nuclear technologies is becoming ever the more pressing.

The Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant in India

One important technology that India is making inroads on is the thorium-fueled fast breeder nuclear reactor. As India’s Department of Atomic Energy clearly recognizes, “We have rather meager reserves of uranium…We, however, have nearly a third of the entire world’s thorium…Our strategies for large scale deployment of nuclear energy must be, and are therefore, focused towards utilisation of thorium.”

India currently has a three-stage nuclear power program that will eventually allow it to make full use of its thorium reserves. In the first stage, the fast neutron reactors that India is developing will burn uranium in pressurized-heavy water reactors to produce plutonium.

During the second stage, the fast neutron reactors will burn the plutonium with a uranium and thorium blanket.  Thorium itself is a fertile element, and while it has the capacity to fission, it needs a boost from low-enriched uranium or plutonium, which can be sourced from spent fuel or decommissioned nuclear weapons.  Thus, using thorium addresses many of the waste disposal, proliferation, and safety hazards that are often associated with conventional, uranium-based nuclear reactors. Investing in thorium-based reactors is cost efficient for India more so than for many other countries for two primary reasons: one being the vast thorium reserves, and the other being its limited reactor base.  Both these factors would reduce the comparative cost that India would undertake with this investment.

Gradually, as the country approaches the third stage of the nuclear program, the reactors will burn the U-233 from the second stage and the fuel blanket will be primarily composed of thorium.  Thus, about two-thirds of the reactor's power will be fueled by thorium.  Additionally, thorium fuel bundles can last much longer than conventional uranium fuel bundles.  Thus, the spent uranium would eventually be replaced by thorium, eventually creating a fully thorium-fueled reactor.

Secretary Condolezza Rice and Indian Foreign Minister Pranab Mukherjee, sign the US-India Civilian Nuclear Cooperation Agreement.

In 2002, construction on a prototype fast breeder reactor at Kalpakkam was approved by the regulatory authority, and this reactor is expected to progress to the second stage of the program by late 2014. Six additional fast reactors are slated for construction, with four of them planned for 2020.

Within 25 years, India plans to increase its use of nuclear power for electricity generation from 2.8% to 9%.  With the passing of the U.S.-India Civil Nuclear Agreement, which allows India even greater independence in the trade of nuclear energy and technologies with other countries, India may eventually establish itself as a preeminent center for nuclear technologies.

Dr. S. Banerjee, Chairman of the Atomic Energy Commission, mentioned in a 2010 address to the IAEA that the Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited is “ready to offer Indian PHWRs of 220 MWe or 540 MWe capacity for export”.  India’s investments will provide India with the electricity capacity that it desperately needs, while simultaneously providing the global energy market with a competitive source of safer and more efficient nuclear energy.  The Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses writes that, “The time has also come for India to think beyond domestic development of nuclear power reactors and showcase its civilian nuclear capabilities abroad.”


Related Media:


Further Reading:



Bagchi, Indrani.  "Nuclear Energy Remains A Non-Negotiable Option for India: Srikumar Banerjee, Former Head, Atomic Energy Commission."  The Economic Times.  Times Internet Limited, 6 May 2012.  Web.  12 July 2012.  

Gupta, Arvind and Sastry Viyyanna.  "Time for India to Export Nuclear Power Reactors and Peaceful Nuclear Technologies.Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses.  Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses, 20 Jan. 2011.  Web.  12 July 2012.  

"India Census: Population Goes Up to 1.21 Billion." The BBC.  The BBC News, 31 March 2011.  Web.  12 July 2012. 

"Indian Energy Sector: An Overview."  India Energy Portal.  The Energy and Resources Institute, n.d.  Web.  12 July 2012.  

India Nuclear Energy.  United Business Media India Limited, n.d.  

"Indira Ghandi Centre for Atomic Research [IGCAR]; Kalpakkam Atomic Reprocessing Plant [KARP]."  GlobalSecurity.org.  GlobalSecurity.org, n.d.  Web.  12 July 2012.  

Martin, Richard.  "Uranium Is So Last Century--Enter Thorium, The New Green Nuke." Wired Magazine.  Condé Nast, 29 Dec. 2009.  Web.  12 July 2012.  

"Nuclear Power in India."  World Nuclear Association.  World Nuclear Association, July 2012.  Web.  12 July 2012. 

"Nuclear Power Safest Among Conventional Options: DAE."  Press Trust of India.  Business Standard, 6 Aug. 2012.  Web.  12 July 2012.  

Sengupta, Somini.  "Thirsting for Energy in India's Boomtowns and Beyond."  The New York Times.  The New York Times Company, 2 March 2008.  Web.  12 July 2012.